The Movie Cricket

Movie reviews by Sean P. Means.

  • The Movie Cricket
  • Sundance
  • Reviews
  • Other writing
  • Review archive
  • About

Anthony Ippolito plays Sylvester Stallone, reenacting one of the classic moments from the 1976 movie “Rocky,” in the biographical drama “I Play Rocky,” directed by Peter Farrelly. (Photo by Claire Folger, courtesy of Amazon MGM Studios.)

Review: 'I Play Rocky' is a charming, cliched look at the making of a classic movie, with Anthony Ippolito impressive as a note-perfect Sylvester Stallone

November 18, 2026 by Sean P. Means

The genre that “I Play Rocky” is working in is technically a biopic, a dramatic recreation of a crucial piece of a real-life person’s life — but, in the telling of how unemployed actor Sylvester Stallone wrote himself a character and held on until Hollywood would let him play it, it’s more accurate to call it a meta-remake of “Rocky.”

Anthony Ippolito stars here as Stallone, who in the early 1970s was a struggling actor in New York, where he has brushes with homelessness and even getting easy cash appearing in soft-core porn. It’s an uncanny portrayal, as Ippolito captures Stallone’s muscular looks and mush-mouth vocal delivery perfectly. (Ippolito played the young Al Pacino in “The Offer,” the miniseries about the making of “The Godfather,” so he’s starting to create a little niche for himself.)

Director Peter Farrelly — in his first movie since the Best Picture Oscar winner “Green Book” (and typing those words together still stings) — and screenwriter Peter Gamble give us Stallone taking guff from his tough-as-nails father, Frank Sr. (Matt Dillon), and pairing Stallone with a supportive girlfriend, Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb). The couple moves to Los Angeles, where Stallone writes screenplays, which Sasha types up, while going to auditions and parking cars at a restaurant where some of the Hollywood big shots dine. 

He manages to snag a meeting with producers Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Toby Kebbell (Robert Chartoff), and impresses them with his intelligence — like appreciating their dance-marathon drama “They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?” because he read the book. He sneaks a copy of one of his scripts into their slush pile, and when they read it, they’re impressed enough to get a studio boss, Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts), to offer Stallone some money to make it.

Stallone has one condition before selling the script — and if you can’t figure out that the condition is also the movie’s title, congratulations on your first day out of that cave.

The back half of “I Play Rocky” is a humorous reenactment that takes us behind the scenes of the making of “Rocky.” Farrelly, a comedy guy before Oscar gold got in his eyes, creates some funny moments of Winkler and Chartoff navigating zero-budget filmmaking, dealing with the abrasive director John G. Avildsen (Jay Duplass), and learning that neither Stallone nor Carl Weathers (Stephan James), the actor hired to play the champ Apollo Creed, actually know how to box. 

The results are charming, even as Farrelly and Gamble work through every trope in the “this is how you make a movie” canon — even a scene where Chartoff and Winkler express doubts when they hear a demo tape of Bill Conti’s iconic fanfare. “I Play Rocky” still works as a rousing movie about an underdog, even if it’s an underdog we’ve loved for half a century.

——

‘I Play Rocky’

★★★

Opens Friday, November 20, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG-13 for strong language, brief sexual material, and smoking. Running time: 128 minutes.

November 18, 2026 /Sean P. Means
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace