Review: 'Edie Arnold Is a Loser' is a goofy Utah-made teen comedy with a punk-rock sentiment, a 'Napoleon Dynamite' vibe and a generous heart
Like many movie critics, I tend to be wary of scrappy low-budget movies made locally — for the same reason restaurant reviewers may not trash a substandard mom-and-pop restaurant, and save their critiques for the really delicious places to go. No critic wants to be the bad guy to someone they might run into in the grocery store.
So the fact that I’m reviewing the Utah-made teen comedy “Edie Arnold Is a Loser” at all is a positive indicator. This is a fun, offbeat and exuberant movie about teen girls chasing a nearly impossible rock ’n’ roll dream so passionately that you’d be made of stone not to want to see them succeed.
The title character, Edie Arnold (played by Adi Madden Cabrera) is a student at Our Lady of Undying Sadness, an all-girl Catholic school. She loves music, though it’s difficult to show that love when she’s assigned to play percussion for the school’s woeful choir, led by the picture-perfect and tone-deaf Kati Vital (Alana Mei Kern). Up in the organ loft, she plays accompaniment with her very nerdy best friend, Frances (McKenna Tuckett), while daydreaming about the cutie from the nearby boys’ school, Walter Boyd (Lucas Van Orden).
Spurred on by Frances, Edie performs a rebellious act, sneaking away from her status-conscious mom (Cherish Rodriguez) to go see a punk band play at a scuzzy music venue. When the girls get there, they learn that the band’s drummer has passed out, and Frances volunteers Edie to fill in. Edie discovers that she likes punk rock, she’s good at playing it, and she wants to play more. Before they know it, Edie and Frances have told everyone — notably the goofy emcee, Iggy (Gabe Root), that they have a band.
The next step for Edie and Frances is to convince the other outcasts at their lunch table, Judith (Niki Rahimi) and Ellen (Alexa Paige), to join their band. They also have to sneak the school’s instruments out of the organ loft, without arousing the suspicion of the school’s cruel disciplinarian, Sister Myra (Star Hermann). Thank heavens for Sister Sheena (Luseane Pasa), the choir director, who thinks Sister Myra needs to unclench her rosary a little.
Directors Megan Rico (who wrote the script, inspired by her own Catholic school days) and Kade Atwood neatly capture the adrenaline rush of teen defiance. There’s a goofiness to the movie’s humor, like in Tuckett’s performance as the anarchic sidekick, that evokes strong comparisons to two more products of the I-15 corridor, “Napoleon Dynamite” and “SLC Punk!”
It’s the sweetness of “Edie Arnold Is a Loser” that puts it more on the “Napoleon Dynamite” side of the Utah movie spectrum. Edie herself, alone or with her bandmates, emerge as a good kid, just trying to find her voice when so many other things – her school, her rivals, the nuns and her mom — want her to be meek and quiet. It’s hard to think of a teen movie character who deserved her punk rebellion more.
——
‘Edie Arnold Is a Loser’
★★★1/2
Opens Friday, September 4, at the Broadway Centre Cinemas (Salt Lake City). Not rated, but probably PG-13 for strong profanity and some sexual dialogue. Running time: 72 minutes.