Who’s the fairest of them all? That’s a high bar for any movie, particularly a remake of a 1937 classic that revolutionized animation and is considered a work of art — but Disney’s 2025 take on “Snow White” is, in its best moments, a pleasant update.
It’s a familiar story, not just from Walt Disney’s beloved “Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs” but centuries of the Brothers Grimm: A princess is born, given the name Snow White, and raised by a kindly king and queen in a kingdom where the royals party with the farmers and bakers and all is well. Then the queen takes ill and dies, and the king is enchanted by a beautiful stranger (played here by Gal Gadot), who gets the king out of the way and sets herself up as a greedy, evil queen.
As the story goes, the Queen also is vain, constantly asking her magic mirror (voiced by Patrick Page) “who’s the fairest of them all?” For many years, the mirror answers that the Queen is the fairest. But as Snow White reaches adulthood, in the form of “West Side Story” star Rachel Zegler, the mirror declares that she, not the Queen, is more fair.
The Queen orders her huntsman (Ansu Kabia) to take Snow into the woods, kill her, and cut out her heart. But the huntsman can’t bring himself to do the deed, and tells Snow to run deep into the forest and hide. After some encounters with grabby tree branches, she lands among some kind forest animals, who lead her to a place to sleep: A cottage inhabited by seven small men. (It’s an interesting exercise the movie sets up to create computer-animated characters who look like the classic cartoon characters, but never use the d-word from the original’s title.)
Highlighting the seven characters is just one example of the constant tug-of-war director Mark Webb (who made the Andrew Garfield “Amazing Spider-Man” movies) and screenwriter Erin Cressida Wilson (whose last script was the adaptation of “The Girl on the Train”) are engaged in with Walt Disney’s source material and his company’s marketing department. As much as they stay close to the original’s visual and musical touchstones, the filmmakers also recognize that this is a different era, and we expect something else from our title heroines.
Ziegler’s Snow White isn’t just wishing for her prince to come, but for her kingdom to return to what it was before the Queen began her evil reign. She’s also wishing — as she explains in her solo “Waiting on a Wish” — for the courage, taught to her by her parents, to act for the good of the people. She gets her first taste of that bravery when she helps a daring bandit, Jonathan, escape the Queen’s clutches.
Jonathan is charming, but he’s no prince. Played by Andrew Burnap (who played Joseph Smth in the miniseries “Under the Banner of Heaven”), Jonathan is reminiscent of the likable rogue Flynn from Disney’s “Tangled.” And, like Flynn and Rapunzel, Jonathan and Snow start out bantering and bickering before the rom-com realizations set in.
Other changes to the plot feel necessary to maintain a PG rating, and are an admission by Disney that some of the darkest moments of the 1937 movie are — and always were — too scary for kids. And some things from the original are just dated; anyone who’s the title character in her own movie in 2025 isn’t sitting around waiting for her prince, but instead taking the fight to the Queen.
Then there are the songs, only three of which have been carried over from the original. Two of them, “Heigh-Ho” and “Whistle While You Work,” are expanded into engaging musical numbers. The third, “The Silly Song,” starts a celebration party that segues to “A Hand Meets a Hand,” a love duet for Zegler and Burnap. The new songs are from Benj Pasek and Justin Paul, the songwriting team behind “La La Land’ and “The Greatest Showman,” and go from forgettable to satisfactory.
One of the better numbers is the Queen’s “All Is Fair,” which feels like something Ursula from “The Little Mermaid” might perform as an encore to “Poor Unfortunate Souls.” Gadot has fun with the song, which is her one opportunity to deliver more than one-note icy villainy.
Zegler is the best thing about this “Snow White.” She’s got the singing voice and the acting chops, proving that her Maria in “West Side Story” wasn’t a one-off. She carries the story, particularly in the reinterpretation of Snow as a princess finding her own way toward leadership rather than being a passive object of other character’s devotion or jealousy. She’s got charisma for miles — and I truly think that Zegler, if pressed, could charm actual woodland creatures, not just computer-animated ones.
There will be fans of Disney’s original who will be upset with the changes Webb and his collaborators have made here. Some of those people have been down on this movie from the moment Zegler, a Latina, was cast as Snow — and were even more dismissive when Zegler posted an emotional response to Donald Trump’s re-election. Just wait until they unpack the story’s politics, of a populist uprising trying to bring down a selfish, self-loving autocrat.
For some fans, I think, the problem is less to do with what the filmmakers have done, and more with the idea that the studio allowed them to change anything at all. That’s an argument that traps the story of Snow White in a glass coffin of nostalgia — lovely to look at, but inert and lifeless. Every generation should have the chance to discover “Snow White” and make it their own, and it shouldn’t take 88 years for the next one.
——
‘Snow White’
★★★
Opens Friday, March 21, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG for violence, some peril, thematic elements and brief rude humor. Running time: 109 minutes.