Review: In 'Wicked: For Good," both Erivo and Grande overcome the deadweight of a bloated two-movie franchise
Fans of last year’s “Wicked” likely will come into the concluding chapter, “Wicked: For Good,” expecting the same bouncy good time, elaborate computer effects to build the world of Oz, and the extraordinary pipes of Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba — well on her way to become the Wicked Witch of the West.
They’ll get the effects, none more spectacular than Erivo’s voice, but the bounce is less bouncy. Instead, director Jon M. Chu leans into the darker corners of the Broadway musical’s second half, as Elphaba and Ariana Grande’s Glinda the Good contend with the power dynamics of an authoritarian wizard (Jeff Goldblum), the fear-mongering propaganda of Madame Morrible (Michelle Yeoh), and how ambition can tear a friendship apart. There’s also a disturbing figure added to the mix, whose face we never see as she cuts a murderous path through Oz — someone by the name of Dorothy.
The second installment of the “Wicked” story starts with Elphaba attacking the Wizard’s troops as they build the Yellow Brick Road using enslaved animal labor. Elphaba trusts, naively, that the people of Oz can be made to understand how badly the Wizard is behaving — not factoring in the ways Morrible uses propaganda and her own magic to turn public sentiment against Elphaba.
Morrible knows that to create a villain, she must also create a hero as an alternative. So she starts working on turning Glinda into that hero — by providing her a bubble chariot, and arranging her wedding to Fiyero (Jonathan Bailey), the captain of the Oz guard. But Fiyero’s heart is set on the person he’s been ordered to hunt down: Elphaba.
The first part of “Wicked” centered on Elphaba’s struggle to be accepted at Shiz University, and her discovery that she — like Morrible and unlike the Wizard or Glinda — actually has magic powers. This allowed Erivo to shine, particularly in the Act One closing number, “Defying Gravity.”
In this second part, the focus is on the relationship between Elphaba and Glinda — and how others, particularly Morrible and the Wizard, try to twist this unlikely friendship into something evil and curdled.
And while Erivo is as strong here as before, the exuberant surprise is Grande’s turn in the tricky role of Glinda. Grande finds the perfect register to display the public persona of the good Glinda, with the mix of emotions — heartbreak, jealousy and (as seen in a childhood flashback) a strong case of imposter syndrome. Grande’s also a gifted comedienne and a dead-solid mimic, and she deploys those talents to concoct a Glinda who’s more tart than the cotton-candy persona.
Still, as with the first movie, there’s a fair amount of bloat in “Wicked: For Good,” including new songs — one for Erivo’s Elphaba and one for Grande’s Glinda — that don’t sparkle as much as the classics, and a few extraneous characters (sorry, Bowen Yang). For artistic reasons, these two films could have been pared down to a solid three-hour spectacle. For financial ones, we get the tail end of the five-hour overkill.
——
‘Wicked: For Good’
★★★
Opens Friday, November 21, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG for action/violence, some suggestive material and thematic material. Running time: 139 minutes.