Review: 'The Testament of Ann Lee' is a riveting and radical account of religious fervor, anchored by Amanda Seyfried's fearless performance
You may not believe me when I say that “The Testament of Ann Lee,” in its radical depiction of the founding of the Shaker movement and its adherence to musical movement and rigid celibacy, is the most profoundly moving film about religious ecstasy I’ve seen in I don’t know when. You’ll have to take it on faith, which is the point of director Mona Fastvold’s daring movie.
It’s the middle of the 18th century in Manchester, England, when Ann Lee — played as an adult by Amanda Seyfried — and her brother William (Lewis Pullman), who have lived a brutal but typical life so far. One of the traumas Ann experiences is seeing her parents having sex, which leads her to believe fornication is sinful and should always be avoided.
One day, Ann, along with Willam and their niece, Nancy (Viola Prettejohn), visit the home of Jane and James Wardley (Stacy Martin and Scott Handy). The Wardleys are Quakers who preach that Jesus will return to Earth as a woman. The Quakers also celebrate their faith with dance, song and impromptu shouting — and Ann quickly takes to this enthusiastic and physical form of worship. Soon she becomes a major member of this group of so-called “shaking Quakers,” or “Shakers.”
Facing persecution in England, Ann and her cohort — which includes her husband, Abraham (Christopher Abbott) — leave for New England. Once there, Nancy leaves the community to marry a new convert, while Abraham leaves Ann because she follows her vow of celibacy.
The Shakers establish a settlement in upstate New York and begin to attract new followers. This time is only a few decades before various religious movements sprung up in this part of the country — notably, Joseph Smith, founder of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Fastvold, working from a script she wrote with her husband, “The Brutalist” director Brady Corbet, captures an era where people are yearning for spiritual answers and seeking them outside their familiar churches. So why wouldn’t a woman who preaches a chaste life filled with making elegantly simple furniture and ritualistically singing and dancing appeal to some people?
It’s in those rituals that Fastvold finds the movie’s power. The film is technically a musical, in that there are many scenes where people are singing and dancing to express their feelings. But it’s not the tuneful jukebox you’d recognize from Broadway or old Hollywood. Instead, Fastvold and composer Daniel Blumberg draw from Shaker hymns to create a series of songs that produce the droning, rhythmic sensation you’d expect from cloistered monks. It’s jarring at first, but as the movie goes, these songs convey a hypnotic grace.
All would be for naught, though, without Amanda Seyfried’s captivating performance at the movie’s center. Though seemingly thin, almost birdlike, Seyfried’s Ann shows herself to be a force of nature, creating a form of worship and an American community through sheer will — and by sharing a fervent conviction that her view of the universe is the correct one. Seyfried’s performance is fearless and astonishing, in a movie that breaks all the rules of what we think a biographical drama should be.
——
‘The Testament of Ann Lee’
★★★1/2
Opens Friday, January 23, in theaters. Rated R for sexual content, graphic nudity, violence and bloody images. Running time: 137 minutes.