The Movie Cricket

Movie reviews by Sean P. Means.

  • The Movie Cricket
  • Sundance 2025
  • Reviews
  • Other writing
  • Review archive
  • About

Lilo (Maia Kealoha) bonds with her “dog,” actually an alien creature she calls Stitch, in “Lilo & Stitch,” a live-action remake of Disney’s 2002 animated movie. (Image courtesy of Disney.)

Review: 'Lilo & Stitch' is a so-so movie for kids, but parents will recognize Disney's cash-grab remake of its animated title

May 22, 2025 by Sean P. Means

Among the live-action remakes Disney has done of its animated movies, “Lilo & Stitch” is not the worst — Robert Zemeckis’ atrocious take on “Pinocchio” has that trophy locked up. And it’s not the most unnecessary one; “The Lion King,” which is the animated version with different animation, holds that title.

The 2025 “Lilo & Stitch” just exists, a serviceable copy of the 2002 animated movie — which is beloved by many who saw it when they were kids, and probably not as good as they remember.

Director Dean Fleischer Camp (who made the sublimely wonderful “Marcel the Shell With Shoes On”) zips fairly quickly through the set-up to the plot: The Galactic Federation catches a rogue genetic experiment, a little blue monster labeled Experient 626, but the thing escapes and lands on an unremarkable planet called Earth. The galactic commander (voiced by Hannah Waddingham) sends two creatures to retrieve 626: Its four-eyed mad-scientist creator, Jumba, and a dweeby one-eyed operative, Pleakley.

The fugitive beast lands on the island of Kauai, where he’s quickly run over by a tour bus and taken to an animal shelter, because the locals have mistaken him for a dog. That’s where the alien meets Lilo, a 6-year-old girl (played by newcomer Maia Kealoha) with a love for Elvis Presley and a talent for getting into mischief. Perhaps that’s why she takes to the odd fuzzball, which she names Stitch.

Lilo’s older sister, Nani (Sydney Elizebeth Agudong), has bigger concerns, like holding down a job, helping herself and Lilo through the grieving process for their parents, ignoring the crush her surfing buddy David (Kaipo Dudoit) has on her, and making sure the town social worker, Mrs. Kekoa (Tia Carrere), doesn’t put Lilo in a foster home. (Fun fact: Carrere voiced the role of Nani in the 2002 movie.)

Nani doesn’t know she’ll have bigger problems, some of them caused by Stitch’s rampant misbehavior — and even more when Jumba and Pleakley, taking human form (specifically, by Zach Galifianakis and Billy Magnussen), start hunting Stitch. There’s also a CIA agent, with the improbable name of Cobra Bubbles (Courtney B. Vance), who arrives in Kauai and goes undercover as Mrs. Kekoa’s supervisor. (This slight alteration to the character cleans up one of the off-key parts of the 2002 version, when the Ving Rhames-voiced Agent Bubbles was ex-CIA and actually was Lilo’s social worker.)

Fleischer Camp doesn’t mess with the core of the story or characters — he’s not allowed when Disney’s quarterly earnings are depending on the movie and its ancillary merchandise — but he and writers Chris Kekaniokalani Bright and Mike Van Waes do some work around the edges to keep the proceedings lively. And Agudong and young Kealoha, as the sisters, give heartfelt and grounded performances despite the computer-animated chaos around them.

It’s hard to find anything really wrong with this version of “Lilo & Stitch” that wasn’t a problem with the first one — namely, a threadbare plot and a labored effort to make Stitch (voiced, then and now, by Chris Sanders, who co-directed the 2002 film) cute instead of vaguely creepy. The biggest problem with this version of “Lilo & Stitch” is that the reasons to make it aren’t cinematic ones but fiduciary ones. Kids may enjoy the slapstick, but the adults accompanying them will only see the ticker of Disney’s share price.

——

‘Lilo & Stitch’

★★

Opens Friday, May 23, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG for action, peril and thematic elements. Running time: 108 minutes.

May 22, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Craig (Tim Robinson, left) kicks off a fast friendship with Austin (Paul Rudd), in writer-director Andrew DeYoung’s comedy “Friendship.” (Photo courtesy of A24.)

Review: 'Friendship' is a comedy that takes apart male relationships, and centers Tim Robinson for some cringe-inducing comic genius

May 22, 2025 by Sean P. Means

Writer-director Andrew DeYoung could have played it safe in his uncomfortable comedy “Friendship,” in which he dissects the nature of male bonding and its opposite in ways that might make the audience’s skin crawl.

DeYoung had already cast Paul Rudd, the Nicest Guy in Movies (trademark pending), as one of the two main male characters here. All he had to do was pick a comic actor with a little bit of edge, but not too much, and watch his movie travel familiar territory to please the audience.

But, no, he cast Tim Robinson, and the cringe factor got kicked up to 11, which is how DeYoung wanted it.

Robinson is famous among fans of nervous comedy for his Netflix sketch show “I Think You Should Leave With Tim Robinson,” where he plays characters in scenarios where things get so tense or unpleasant that one of the characters has to hit the eject button.

If you haven’t watched the show, you may be familiar with the most famous meme it produced — a sketch where a hot-dog car crashes into a clothing shop and Robinson’s character, a guy in a hot dog costume, tries to avoid blame for it.

In DeYoung’s comedy, Robinson plays Craig, a suburban dad and husband who works for a company that makes phone apps and other things more addictive. His wife, Tami (Kate Mara), is a cancer survivor who’s running a florist business from their dining table, and keeps asking Craig to buy a van so she doesn’t have to cram her deliveries in their hatchback.

One evening, Tami asks Craig to walk a misaddressed package to the new neighbors a few doors down. That’s how Craig first connects with Austin, Rudd’s character, a TV weatherman who is everything Craig is not: Cool, confident and affable. And, because he is all these things, Austin invites Craig to hang out — and even explore the secret passages under their town.

It’s when Austin invites Craig to be part of his established friend group that things go off the rails — because Craig, incapable of reading social cues, takes things too far. 

What follows, as Craig desperately tries to re-create the magic of his brief friendship with Austin, is by turns funny, unsettling and even sometimes cruel — to the other characters and to the audience.

DeYoung, a TV director making his feature film debut, perfectly calibrates how far Robinson will take a joke, then deploys Robinson like a missile at the comedic target. The result is a caustic, biting look at every idea we have about toxic male behavior in the 21st century.

Some may find it too mean-spirited — but if you can tune into DeYoung’s wavelength, there’s enough laughter amid the cringe to make “Friendship” a place worth hanging out.

——

‘Friendship’

★★★

Opens Friday, May 23, in theaters everywhere. Rated R for language and some drug content. Running time: 100 minutes. 

May 22, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Tony Todd, who died in November 2024, makes his last appearance as William Bludworth, a coroner who knows how Death works, in “Final Destination: Bloodlines,” the sixth movie in the franchise. (Photo by Eric Milner, courtesy of New Line Cinema / Warner Bros. Entertainment.)

Review: 'Final Destination: Bloodlines' is a fitfully clever horror contraption, and a tender sendoff to the iconic actor Tony Todd

May 15, 2025 by Sean P. Means

Watching a “Final Destination” movie is like watching someone play the children’s game “Mouse Trap” — you see the pieces placed to start the chain reaction of events, then watch in delight as those steps play out exactly as you expect.

The sixth chapter of the franchise, “Final Destination: Bloodlines” — which is also the first made since “Final Destination 5” back in 2011 — follows the familiar formula, with a few gruesome surprises along the way.

The opening sequence is worth the price of admission. It’s set in 1962, where a young man, Paul (Max Lloyd-Jones), is taking his girlfriend, Iris (Brec Bassinger), out to a special dinner on the opening night of The Skyview, a restaurant atop a high tower that I’m sure the lawyers representing Seattle’s Space Needle have made clear bears no resemblance to their client’s landmark. Iris sees the whole evening end in disaster, as the tower falls apart and people in cartoonishly nasty ways — except that in the cartoons, Wile E. Coyote wasn’t crushed into a bloody pulp.

The opening is too good to sustain, and it turns out it doesn’t have to. The Skyview disaster is seen in the nightmares of a present-day college student, Stefani Reyes (Kaitlyn Santa Juana), which are so disturbing they’re messing with her sleep cycle and her grades. So she goes home to ask her relatives about what she’s seen, particularly Iris, the woman at the center of it all.

Iris turns out to be a sore subject for the family, who finally divulge that Iris is Stefani’s long-absent grandmother — whose paranoia about death made her obsessive and drove her away from her two children, Stefani’s absentee mom Darlene (Rya Kihlstedt) and her uncle, Harold (Alex Zahara). Stefani goes to talk to Grandma Iris (Gabrielle Rose), and finds her in a heavily fortified cabin deep in the woods, working to cheat Death.

Stefani discovers that her dream of Iris at The Skyview wasn’t a dream, but a premonition Iris had while on the tower’s observation deck — and her warning got everyone out of the place before it collapsed. After that, Grandma Iris tells Stefani, Death is working to pick off all the people who should have died in The Skyview disaster, and because that’s a multi-decade task, Death is trying to take out the children of those people. (Apparently, Death obeys the same rules of succession as the British royal family: After Iris is out, Death goes after Harold, but then goes after Harold’s kids before going after Darlene and her children.)

Directors Adam Stein and Zach Lipovsky, following a sometimes-clever script by Guy Busick and Lori Evans Taylor, stage some elaborate scenes where all the ways someone can die are put into motion, and it’s a waiting game to see which one will do the job. There’s a good one fairly early during a backyard barbecue at Harold’s house, where shards of glass in an ice bucket, a rake under a trampoline, and various gardening implements are set in place waiting for their turn. (I didn’t spoil too much, as this sequence is shown in the trailer.)

The other cool thing in “Final Destination: Bloodlines” is the swan-song performance by Tony Todd, playing the mysterious coroner, William Bludworth, for the fourth and final time. Todd, 69, died from cancer last November, and was clearly ill when the movie was filmed some six months earlier. (The movie is dedicated to his memory.) Gaunt and careworn, Todd recites a short but memorable monologue about the inevitability of death and the preciousness of every second of life. His words and their meaningful delivery transcend horror movies and become a coda for what appears to be a life well lived.

——

‘Final Destination: Bloodlines’

★★★

Opens Friday, May 16, in theaters everywhere. Rated R for strong violent/grisly accidents, and language. Running time: 110 minutes.

May 15, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Amina (Jenna Ortega, top) torments The Weeknd (Abel Tesfaye, known in his music career as The Weeknd) in the musical drama “Hurry Up Tomorrow.” (Photo by Andrew Cooper, courtesy of Lionsgate.)

Review: 'Hurry Up Tomorrow' is a disaster of a music movie, a vanity project for The Weeknd with abstract visuals and jumbled storytelling

May 15, 2025 by Sean P. Means

Somewhere between failed experiment and vanity project sits “Hurry Up Tomorrow,” a tediously arty mess of a movie in which the fledgling actor Abel Tesfaye — better known to the world as the musical star The Weeknd — tries to get you to buy his album while also arguing how horrible it is to be a rock star.

Tesfaye’s character here happens to be called The Weeknd, and he’s an internationally famous performer who fills arenas with adoring fans wanting to hear his sing his songs. Backstage, though, he’s a miserable mess, listening to the voice message left behind by the woman who’s leaving him. There’s an entourage just out of view, and the only person we see on The Weeknd’s side is his smarmy Irish manager, played by Barry Keoghan.

As director Trey Edward Shults (“Waves,” “It Comes at Night,” “Krisha”) follows The Weeknd through his self-inflicted spiral of depression, he also follows another character — played by Jenna Ortega — whose connection to the rocker is not clear. This woman, called Amina in the credits and nowhere else, is busy walking through a remote house in Montana, pouring out a can of gasoline and setting it on fire.

Shults spends a long time creating artfully abstract images of Tesfaye in his funk, while Ortega’s character drives away from the burning house and into the night. The script — by Shults, Tesfaye and Reza Fahim — is so vague that a viewer might surmise that Ortega’s character is the woman who was breaking up with The Weeknd via voice message. But, at the 40-minute mark, we see them meet for the first time.

There’s an instant connection, and the two seem to be falling in love without ever saying the words. After a night in a fancy hotel room, away from The Weeknd’s manager, Amina finds The Weeknd to be distant and self-involved — nothing like the man who fell in love with her the night before. Then things take a turn toward Stephen King’s “Misery.”

So, as that synopsis indicates, not much in “Hurry Up Tomorrow” makes a lick of sense. And if you were hoping hearing new cuts from The Weeknd’s new album — for which an ad and a music video are served to viewers before the movie “officially” begins — will find the songs dreary, particularly compared to The Weeknd’s better-known hits, which Amina comically dissects before a tied-up Mr. Weeknd.

Shults is a gifted director, and his arresting imagery works to hold the viewer’s attention when everything else fails to do that. Here’s hoping he will bounce back from this tiresome misfire, which is as much of an endurance test as — if you believe Tesfaye — being a ridiculously famous rock star.

——

‘Hurry Up Tomorrow’

★1/2

Opens Friday, May 16, in theaters everywhere. Rated R for language throughout, drug use, some bloody violence and brief nudity. Running time: 105 minutes.

May 15, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Ethan Hunt (Tom Cruise) hangs from the axle of a biplane, in one of the stunt sequences from “Mission: Impossble - The Final Reckoning,” the eighth movie in the action franchise. (Photo courtesy of Paramount Pictures / Skydance.)

Review: 'Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning' lets Tom Cruise deliver the stunts, in a bloated story propped up by callbacks to past installments

May 14, 2025 by Sean P. Means

Like a good magician, “Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning” does a very good job of misdirection — of putting so many spectacular stunts and cool set pieces in front of the viewer that they will be tempted not to notice the flimsy framework that is barely holding it together.

The eighth installment of the movie franchise, started 29 years ago when star Tom Cruise was a mere lad of 33, is a nearly three-hour effort to wow audiences. It’s also a brazen attempt to gaslight the audience, to make them believe that the three decades of these frenetic, disjointed movies were following some kind of master plan.

It’s breathtakingly impressive that director Christopher McQuarrie, who will now be known for directing the last four movies in this franchise, and his co-writer, Erik Jendresen, have cobbled together enough callbacks and returning characters to create a grand facade of continuity. But if you think movie buffs are going to buy the idea that past franchise directors Brian De Palma, John Woo, J.J. Abrams and Brad Bird were all conspirators in a grand cohesive narrative, you’ve got another thing coming.

The new movie picks up pretty much where the last movie, subtitled “Dead Reckoning,” left off — with Cruise’s intrepid Ethan Hunt in a bind. An AI program called The Entity has taken over cyberspace, manipulating people’s information, and making them believe the world’s great powers are at each other’s throats. It’s also inspired a doomsday cult that has infiltrated law enforcement and government agencies everywhere. And The Entity’s next step is to breach the security systems of nuclear arsenals in the nine countries that have them. If it weren’t so creepily close to current events, it would be comical.

Ethan is also on the run from, well, everybody — and has gone into hiding in London’s Underground. The only person with enough juice to get a message to him is the president of the United States, Erika Sloane (Angela Bassett), who, incidentally, been in office since 2018’s “Fallout.” 

Ethan has a daring plan to stop The Entity, a convoluted plot that involves retrieving a box with The Entity’s original source code, pairing it with a digital “poison pill” devised by tech genius Luther Stickell (Ving Rhames, the only actor besides Cruise to appear in all eight movies), and downloading it into The Entity. 

There are numerous problems with this plan: The box is inside a sunken Russian sub at the bottom of the Arctic Ocean; Sloane and her top advisers want to keep Ethan locked up; and one of The Entity’s human operatives, Gabriel (Esai Morales), is out for revenge on Ethan. (None of these are spoilers, as they were laid out pretty clearly in “Dead Reckoning.”)

But even getting through this set-up seems to take an eternity — it’s 23 minutes before the title credits appear — in a movie that clocks in a bit shy of three hours. McQuarrie weighs down the exposition with a ton of callbacks, mentioning everything from Jon Voight’s character in the first movie to the bombing of the Kremlin in the fourth, “Ghost Protocol.” There’s one callback that’s actually quite charming, involving an actor named Rolf Saxon, who appeared in the first movie in 1996 and hasn’t been seen since.

All those references to the previous chapters are meant to serve a purpose, to invest Ethan Hunt’s endless lone-wolf battles against evil with an air of destiny — a word that’s overused in the movie’s ponderous dialogue, with many scenes of other characters telling Ethan the fate of the world is, again, on his shoulders.

The story puts us back with Ethan’s support team: Tech expert Benji Dunn (Simon Pegg), pickpocket Grace (Hayley Atwell), French assassin Paris (Pom Klementieff), and cop-turned-ally Degas (Greg Tarzan Davis). Each gets some interesting bit of business, though they’re mostly there to give Cruise’s Hunt what he needs at the exact moment he needs it to save the world.

When McQuarrie and Cruise dispense with the blah-blah-blah, they move into a series of dynamic set pieces. There are some smartly executed hand-to-hand fight scenes on a U.S. submarine and an Arctic outpost, a nifty bit with Cruise in diving gear on that Russian sub, and a climax involving biplanes that — as the movie’s marketing has already shown us — features Cruise himself hanging on a wing and getting his face whipped by the onrush of air.

The action sequences are a reminder that the “Mission: Impossible” movie franchise isn’t a cerebral cat-and-mouse game, the way Bruce Geller’s ‘60s TV series was. It’s a stunt show, which has seen Cruise morph into a do-it-yourself action performer in the spirit of Jackie Chan. Pretending otherwise wastes the filmmakers’ time and the audience’s patience. Cruise and McQuarrie have a mission, which they’ve chosen to accept, to pump up the intensity and letting logic self-destruct.

——

‘Mission: Impossible - The Final Reckoning’

★★★

Opens Friday, May 23, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG-13 for sequences of strong violence and action, bloody images, and brief language. Running time: 169 minutes.

May 14, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Frendo the Clown gets ready to bust up a teen kegger in an abandoned corn syrup factory, in the horror comedy “Clown in a Cornfield.” (Photo courtesy of RLJE Films and Shudder.)

Review: 'Clown in a Cornfield' is a horror comedy that delivers the blood with a justified sense of irony

May 08, 2025 by Sean P. Means

The title really says it all: “Clown in a Cornfield.” Read it cold, without any preparation, and you’d guess that it’s a horror movie — but what you wouldn’t guess is that it’s a pretty good one, working within and sometimes toying with the parameters of the teen slasher movie.

High school senior Quinn (Katie Douglas) is not pleased that she and her dad (Aaron Abrams) have relocated to the small town of Kettle Springs, Missouri, which is economically depressed ever since a fire destroyed the town’s main industry, a corn syrup factory. But Quinn soon befriends some of her classmates, who spend their spare time making YouTube videos in which they have reimagined the factory’s happy mascot, Frendo the Clown, into a psychotic killer.

Quinn gets a fright the first time the other teens surprise her with a Frendo jump-scare. But when a couple of the teens are murdered bloodily, Quinn realizes someone else is using Frendo for their own nasty purposes. Unfortunately, Quinn’s new friends — led by the swoon-inducing Cole (Carson MacCormac) — have a reputation for mischief, and neither Sheriff Dunn (Will Sasso) or the town’s leading businessman, Mr. Hill (Kevin Durant), believe them. (I should mention that Mr. Hill is Cole’s father.)

Then director Eli Craig — whose first movie was the clever horror-comedy “Tucker and Dale vs. Evil” — and co-writer Carter Blanchard up the stakes, and the chances for mayhem, with a twist I will not spoil.

Craig finds a nice balance between scary and silly in this gore-fest. The horror set pieces are smartly staged, and the teen heroes are engaging. That’s especially true of Douglas, who has a pleasant Jenna Ortega vibe and could easily graduate to bigger things after this. 

Needless to say, if horror’s not your bag, there’s nothing in “Clown in a Cornfield” that’s going to change your position. But for lovers of meat-and-potatoes slasher movies, it delivers with a dose of ironic detachment.

——

‘Clown in a Cornfield’

★★★

Opens Friday, May 9, in theaters. Rated R for bloody horror violence, language throughout and teen drinking. Running time: 97 minutes.

May 08, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

Artists Colin Brass, left, and Greta Scheing sit in the space they and other artists reclaimed in a Providence, Rhode Island, shopping mall, captured in the documentary “Secret Mall Apartment.” (Photo courtesy of MTuckman Media.)

Review: 'Secret Mall Apartment' captures a clever artists' project, but doesn't go deep into why it happened

May 08, 2025 by Sean P. Means

The documentary “Secret Mall Apartment” captures how a group of artists created a space to live, and simulate a home, in an unused space in a New England shopping mall — but the movie is so intent on showing how they did it, they give short shrift to the question of why they did it.

The project started in 2003, shortly after the Providence Place Mall opened in Providence, Rhode Island. Eight people — Michael Townsend, an art teacher at the Rhode Island School of Design, and some friends and students, along with his then-wife, Ardriana Valdez-Young — found the space, in a corner created by the mall’s odd architecture, where they could set up a place of their own. 

Of course, they have a cheap camera to capture their actions on video, the footage from which director Jeremy Workman uses to tell much of the story.

The artists string an extension cord to bring electricity to the space. They go to the Salvation Army thrift store for a couch and other furniture. And, most importantly, they figure out how to get in with these bulky items without attracting the attention of the mall’s security team.

Through interviews with the artists themselves, Workman captures the excitement and adventure of their hidden art project, as the eight of them describe their close calls and their life hacks — like the amount of movie-theater popcorn they ate while staying there.

Townsend is essentially the hero of the piece, and Workman devotes a great deal of time to what’s essentialy the art teacher’s day job: Creating murals out of masking tape for the local children’s hospital, and teaching the young patients to join in — creating a bit of whimsy and joy in a sad and scary place. 

But when Workman could dig a bit deeper, asking Townsend and the others to explore what was behind the apartment project — beyond the facile discussions of gentrification, urban blight and rampant capitalism — the movie instead becomes a parody of itself. The second half of the documentary consists of an effort by the production to duplicate the apartment on a soundstage, a move that’s too cutesy for the movie’s own good. In the end, the real secrets of “Secret Mall Apartment” remain frustratingly underexplored.

——

‘Secret Mall Apartment’

★★1/2

Opens Friday, May 9, at the Broadway Centre Cinemas (Salt Lake City). Not rated, but probably R for language and some references to drug use. Running time: 92 minutes.

May 08, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment

True-crime internet influencer Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick, at right), with her publisher, Vicky (Alex Newell, second from right), join her former nemesis, Emily Nelson (Blake Lively, left), and Emily’s fiancé, Dante (Michele Morroni), for a wedding on the island of Capri, in director Paul Feig mystery/comedy “Another Simple Favor.” (Photo courtesy of Amazon MGM Studios.)

Review: 'Another Simple Favor' brings Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively back for martinis and murder, but the mix of comedy and blood doesn't sparkle this time

May 01, 2025 by Sean P. Means

There’s a lot I will tolerate in order to watch Anna Kendrick having fun as she tears into a comedic role — and there’s a lot one must tolerate surrounding Kendrick in “Another Simple Favor,” a mishmash of martini-swigging comedy and bloody murder mystery that doesn’t quite get the recipe right.

Director Paul Feig got that balance perfect in 2018’s “A Simple Favor,” in which Kendrick played Stephanie Smothers, suburban mom and baking vlogger — now we’d say “influencer,” I suppose — who becomes fascinated with a sophisticated new mom at her son’s school, Emily (Blake Lively). When Emily disappears, Stephanie became neighborhood sleuth, though she took time out for a romp in the sheets with Emily’s novelist husband, Sean (Henry Golding). 

You may remember — and if you didn’t, I’m about to spoil a 7-year-old movie — that Emily faked her own death by killing her secret twin sister. And she would have gotten away with it if it wasn’t for that meddling Stephanie.

The new movie starts with Stephanie, who has graduated online from baking videos to true-crime case-solving, at a bookstore reading for her first book — which is all about her strange encounter with Emily. Who should walk in to the reading but the recently sprung-from-prison Emily. Stephanie fears Emily is seeking revenge, but her request is even more unsettling: Emily wants Stephanie to be her maid of honor at her destination wedding in Capri.

Stephanie takes the trip, still suspicious of Emily – but soon discovering there’s a lot more she should be suspicious about. Like the fact that Emily’s fiancé, Dante (Michele Morrone), is apparently part of the Mafia, and that the family’s matriarch, Portia (Elena Sofia Ricci), vocally despises her prospective daughter-in-law. Or the fact that Emily’s estranged mom (Elizabeth Perkins) shows up, seemingly in the throes of dementia, accompanied by Emily’s previously unseen Aunt, Linda (Allison Janney), who’s way too nice to be real. Or the fact that her son, Nicky (Ian Ho), is being chaperoned by Emily’s now ex-husband, Sean, who’s frequently soused.

With all this animosity brewing under the Mediterranean sun, it shouldn’t be a surprise that the movie’s first murder isn’t too far away. But who? And why? That’s what Stephanie wants to figure out — in part because the incompetent Caprese police detective in charge (Max Malatesta) thinks she’s the killer.

The script, by Jessica Sharzer — who adapted Darcey Bell’s novel for the first movie — and Laeta Kalogridis (“Alita: Battle Angel”), doesn’t have the same heady fizz of its predecessor. Emily’s sinister banter has more of a nasty edge, without being as smart. And the writers rely too much on chemical enhancement (gin in one scene, truth serum in another) to make Stephanie artificially ditzy for comical effect.

Kendrick and Lively are clearly enjoying their characters’ love-hate relationship, and both performers get some nice moments where both Emily and Stephanie think they’ve got everything figured out. But if one person involved in this movie has nailed the assignment, it’s costume designer Renée Ehrlich Kalfus, another crew member returning from the first movie, who finds gorgeous couture — especially for Lively — that is both drop-dead sexy and hilariously too much.

For most of the movie, I was on the fence about whether I was enjoying it. Then there’s a big twist at the end — which is both outlandish and tiresomely predictable, and shows how desperate everyone involved was to figure out the secret sauce that made the first movie so enjoyable. That twist knocked me off the fence and into the “no” camp, in spite of Kendrick’s charms. 

——

‘Another Simple Favor’

★★1/2

Available Thursday, May 1, streaming on Prime. Rated R for violence, sexual content, nudity, language throughout, and suicide. Running time: 120 minutes.

May 01, 2025 /Sean P. Means
Comment
  • Newer
  • Older

Powered by Squarespace