Review: 'Shortcomings' is a funny, smart take on Asian identity, and a sharp directing debut for actor Randall Park

On the blurry line between defending one’s ethnic identity and finding one’s own self lies “Shortcomings,” a funny and thoughtful anti-romantic comedy that’s a strong directing debut for actor Randall Park.

Ben, played by Justin H. Min, runs a failing independent movie theater in Berkeley, Calif., and once harbored dreams of being a filmmaker. As a Japanese American movie snob, he’s particularly incensed about Hollywood movies with mostly Asian casts pandering to the worst impulses of rom-com sentimentality. (The movie opens with such a scene, featuring Stephanie Hsu and Ronny Chieng, that’s a diss clearly aimed at “Crazy Rich Asians.”) 

Ben’s girlfriend, Miko (Ally Maki), works with the Asian American film festival that booked that Hollywood product, so the drive home devolves into the latest in a series of arguments the couple has had recently. Another argument starts when Miko finds porn websites on Ben’s laptop, all of them featuring white women — which, Miko argues, shows Ben’s a hypocrite because he always says his preferences are toward Asian women.

Ben’s olher conversation partner is Alice (played by comedian Sherry Cola), a tart-tongued lesbian college student who can’t seem to go two days without falling in love with some attractive woman — such as the waitress at their favorite diner. Alice is also the only person who can successfully call Ben out on his bullcrap, particularly when he talks about Miko. 

Miko soon tells Ben she’s been picked for a three-month internship — which, she says curtly, is a good time to press pause on their relationship. While Miko’s gone, Ben plunges back into the dating scene, first with Autumn (Tavi Gevinson), a performance artist he hired to staff the theater’s box office, and Sasha (Debby Ryan), whom Ben meets at one of Alice’s parties. Yes, both Autumn and Sasha are white, seemingly bolstering Miko’s case for Ben’s hypocrisy. 

Adrian Tomine’s script, based on his graphic novel, is handled as a series of vignettes that depict Ben’s slow unraveling, and the question of whether he’s a misunderstood defender of Asian American integrity (his P.O.V.) or just a self-centered jerk (everyone else’s view). Director Park — best known for playing the dad on “Fresh Off the Boat,” and FBI agent Jimmy Woo in the Marvel franchise — does Tomine’s story proud, generating a ton of laughs and more than a few insights that upend the romantic-comedy cliches.

Min is outstanding as Ben, which will be no surprise to those who caught him in “After Yang” last year. The supporting cast — which includes Jacob Batalon (from the “Spider-Man” movies) and Sonoya Mizuno (who was the bride in “Crazy Rich Asians”) — is stellar, with Cola shining brightest as the frequently lovelorn Alice. Together with Park’s smart direction, they make “Shortcomings” the AAPI-affirming movie Ben himself might have made if he wasn’t so self-absorbed.

——

‘Shortcomings’

★★★1/2

Opens Friday, August 4, in theaters. Rated R for language throughout, sexual material and brief nudity.  Running time: 95 minutes.

——

This review first appeared on this website on January 23, 2023, when the movie premiered at the 2023 Sundance Film Festival.