Review: 'Moana' delivers a live-action copy of the 2016 animated story that's too timid to go for anything deeper
Disney’s latest live-action remake of one of its animated movies, “Moana” has the same characters, the same music and the same sprightly pace of the 2016 original. What it lacks is a reason, other than to fill Disney’s coffers, to exist.
It’s only been 10 years since the animated “Moana” delivered us a new kind of Disney princess — a stubborn and resilient Pacific Islander teen who is called to the ocean and works to restore balance to nature and save her village. And less than two years since Disney brought that girl back in the animated “Moana 2,” as determined as ever to connect people across the sea.
So why go back to the original live-action “Moana” now? Because Disney has found that maintaining its intellectual property across platforms, from animation to live action to branding opportunities, makes the shareholders happy. And, as evidenced by last year’s ho-hum live-action remake of “Lilo & Stitch,” the audience will go along with the money grab if it means they can keep their kids entertained for 90 minutes.
Providing a synopsis of the new “Moana” is almost unnecessary, because it’s almost beat-for-beat the same as the original. Teen Moana (voiced by newcomer Catherine Laga’aia) is drawn to the ocean, even though her father, Chief Tui (John Tai), warns her that no one on their island has ever gone past the reef. But when the coconut trees are hit by blight and the village fishermen return with empty nets, Moana senses that the solution lies out in the far-off ocean.
With a nudge from her grandma (played by the great Maori star Rena Owen), Moana learns that her people weren’t always stuck on land, but were great voyagers on the ocean. So she heads out determined to save her village by finding a magical stone and reuniting it with the island goddess Tefiti. To do that, she must enlist the demigod who first stole the stone, Maui — who’s played by the same actor who voiced the character 10 years ago: Dwayne Johnson.
This casting may be the central flaw with this version of “Moana.” As a cartoon, Maui was a perfect comic creation, an eight-foot slab of pumped-up muscles who dwarfs the very human Moana — and Johnson’s voice, particularly singing “You’re Welcome,” a Lin-Manuel Miranda-written song that makes the most of his limited vocal range, remains a delight. But the very human Johnson doesn’t look that much like a demigod (even if he is 6-foot-5 next to Laga’aia’s 5-foot-2 frame).
Director Thomas Kail, best known for staging Miranda’s “Hamilton” (and directing the live-to-tape version on Disney+), colors safely within the prescribed Disney lines, never getting too far away from the imagery or characters the 2016 version burned into our collective brains. It’s an odd irony that in a movie about a young woman finding the courage to go beyond the reef, this “Moana” never gets out of the shallow end of the pool.
——
‘Moana’
★★
Opens Friday, July 10, in theaters everywhere. Rated PG for action/peril, some scary images, rude humor and brief thematic elements. Running time: 115 minutes.